Skip to article content
NUMERISH / INSIGHTSManufacturing

Why did this production run cost more than planned?

Trace a production cost variance through material issues, yield, quality holds and finished stock. See how Manufacturing360 supports decisions about repeat orders.

A yellow industrial robot operates beside machinery on a production line.
Manufacturing / Numerish Insight
Jump to a section
  1. 01Start with the revision that reached the line
  2. 02Work out the cost of a lower yield
  3. 03Make the next planning meeting specific

Two runs of the same product can consume similar quantities of material and produce very different margins. The difference may be in the number of saleable units. If planning counts everything coming off the line as available stock, sales can take orders against units that quality has yet to release.

Manufacturing360’s production workflow gives planners, stores, quality and the plant controller a common reference in the work order. Following that order from the released specification to finished stock helps a team decide whether to repeat a run, investigate yield or change a promise to a customer.

Start with the revision that reached the line

Before release, identify the bill of materials revision, expected output, tooling and line capacity. At issue, record the component lots and units of measure. A substitution might be appropriate, but it needs an authorised record. Otherwise the controller is later comparing the plan for one material with the actual cost of another.

During the run, separate good output, scrap and units awaiting inspection. A rejected lot needs a disposition. If rework is approved, retain its link to the original order so that the extra labour and materials can be explained. See the Manufacturing360 production lifecycle.

Work out the cost of a lower yield

Suppose a run consumes 12,000 in production cost. At a planned output of 1,000 good units, that is 12 per unit. If only 900 units are released and the rest are scrap with no recovery value, the same total spread over the released units is about 13.33 per unit. This simplified comparison assumes the entire cost is attributed to those good units.

Before repricing the next order, check whether the missing 100 were actually scrap. If they are on hold for inspection, the immediate issue is availability. If they are rework, the final cost and yield are still open. The same apparent shortfall leads to three different operating decisions.

Make the next planning meeting specific

Pick one finished lot. Ask stores to trace it to the consumed lots, quality to show its release decision and finance to explain the difference between planned and actual cost. Track released yield and the age of unresolved quality holds together. Those measures let a planner distinguish a capacity problem from an inspection backlog. Follow the manufacturing workflow from planning to cost close.

KEEP EXPLORING

More to discover in Numerish.

Explore related insights and practical enterprise workflows.

Browse all insights
FROM INSIGHT TO ACTION

Put the ideas to work.

Explore connected workflows for manufacturing businesses.

Explore Manufacturing